Applying Tim Cain’s 9 Quest Types to Build Better Multiplayer Objectives

Stop repeating the same three objectives — make multiplayer feel like a living RPG

If your players complain that every match feels like "another capture point or fetch quest," you're hearing the single biggest retention problem in modern shooters: stale objectives. Designers want variety, players want clear goals, and studios want predictable engineering costs. The good news: Tim Cain's classic RPG quest taxonomy gives us a proven design language to expand multiplayer objectives without blowing the budget. This article translates Cain's nine quest types into actionable objective blueprints for multiplayer games — with practical examples ARC Raiders and other shooters can implement in 2026 and beyond.

“More of one thing means less of another.” — Tim Cain (as reported by PC Gamer).

Why Tim Cain's quest types matter for multiplayer objective design in 2026

Tim Cain distilled RPG quest design into nine archetypes to help writers and designers intentionally vary player chores. Translating those archetypes to multiplayer gives us a fast, flexible palette of objective patterns that maintain clarity for players while enabling emergent play. In 2026, this matters more than ever because:

• Live-service shooters (like ARC Raiders) are doubling down on map variety and asymmetric modes — players expect fresh objectives across smaller and larger arenas.
• AI-driven event systems let studios spawn dynamic objectives mid-match, so quest archetypes can be threaded together procedurally.
• Telemetry and real-time analytics enable rapid iteration; you can A/B test objective variants and reward curves to tune engagement without guessing.

How to read this guide

Below I map each of Tim Cain's nine quest types into: a concise multiplayer translation, a concrete ARC Raiders-style objective example, implementation notes, balancing tips, and telemetry signals to monitor. Use these patterns as building blocks to assemble single-match objectives, seasonal meta-goals, or procedural in-match events.

Tim Cain’s nine quest types — translated for multiplayer

1. Eliminate / Kill (Assassination)

Multiplayer translation: remove an enemy, AI target, or high-value unit from the match.

ARC Raiders example: "Neutralize the Scourge Handler" — a high-health AI commander spawns near the center of Blue Gate and grants the allied team an adaptive buff when killed.

• Design pattern: focal objective with clear audio/visual telegraphing and a short vulnerability window to reward timing and teamwork.
• Implementation notes: scalable health and resistances, anti-camping mechanics (the boss moves or shields intermittently), and soft timers so the match doesn't stall.
• Balancing: tune XP/currency and short-term team buffs rather than permanent power spikes; avoid single-player carry scenarios by requiring multiple roles to reach the boss (tank to distract, DPS to burst, support to debuff).
• Telemetry: time-to-kill distribution, percent of matches where a team kills the boss, and post-kill win rate.

2. Retrieve / Fetch

Multiplayer translation: bring an item from point A to point B, or recover a dropped objective under pressure.

ARC Raiders example: "Data Crate Recovery" — an encrypted crate spawns in a contested zone; teams must take it to their extraction zone. Crates can be dropped on damage and be picked up by enemies.

• Design pattern: risk/reward loop that creates mobile skirmish hotspots and encourages defensive play around carriers.
• Implementation notes: implement carrier debuffs (slower sprint, audible cues) and carrier-pass mechanics for teamwork. Provide visual signals so enemies can decide whether to engage or flank.
• Balancing: consider multiple crate rarities for varied risk: higher-value crates give bigger rewards but spawn deeper in the map.
• Telemetry: pickup-to-extract time, carrier deaths, assist ratios, and frequency of theft mechanics.

3. Escort / Protect

Multiplayer translation: guard a moving asset or NPC as it traverses the map, or protect a stationary objective under periodic threats.

ARC Raiders example: "Escort the Power Relay" — an autonomous drone carries a power relay that must safely cross a long corridor to power a new terminal. Attackers can hack the drone to slow it or summon NPC blockers.

• Design pattern: creates shifting frontlines and requires coordination around choke points.
• Implementation notes: to prevent griefing, give builders (or engineers) a repair window and ensure the drone has predictable waypoints rather than random paths.
• Balancing: give attackers alternative pathways or secondary objectives to avoid stalemates; keep escort duration within average session length targets (8–12 minutes for 2026’s quick-match audiences).
• Telemetry: number of successful escorts, average escort duration, and time spent in choke zones.

4. Deliver / Push (Delivery)

Multiplayer translation: move payloads or dominate corridors to flip objectives — a steady, contested progress bar mechanic.

ARC Raiders example: "Power Conduit" — teams alternate pushing a conduit across the map. Successful pushes unlock temporary map advantages.

• Design pattern: continuous, momentum-based objective useful for matches with ebb-and-flow pacing.
• Implementation notes: use multiple lanes and periodic environmental events (in 2026, AI weather or map hazards) to create strategic choices.
• Balancing: introduce catch-up mechanics and time-limited windows where the conduit moves faster to prevent snowballing.
• Telemetry: push rate per minute, number of lead changes, and comeback frequency.

5. Investigate / Intel (Exploration)

Multiplayer translation: find clues, hack terminals, or unveil hidden map information to unlock advantages or narrative beats.

ARC Raiders example: "Archive Nodes" — hidden terminals around Stella Montis that when unlocked reveal temporary enemy positions and spawn a mini-objective.

• Design pattern: rewards map knowledge and risk-taking, perfect for players who prefer stealth, scouting, or tactical utility roles.
• Implementation notes: nodes should have varying difficulty (locked behind light puzzles, combat encounters, or platforming) and offer short-lived team-wide perks (map reveal for 20 seconds).
• Balancing: avoid one-button reveals: make discovery meaningful but not game-deciding; couple intel with follow-up objectives so teams must act on information.
• Telemetry: percentage of nodes discovered, follow-up objective completion rate, and intel exploitation (how often revealed info yields a kill or capture).

6. Puzzle / Interaction

Multiplayer translation: non-combat objectives that require coordination, timed interactions, or spatial reasoning to solve.

ARC Raiders example: "Energy Matrix" — teams must align three consoles in sequence under pressure. Failing the sequence spawns enemy reinforcements.

• Design pattern: creates role interplay (communication, sequencing, timing) and gives tactical players a non-lethal win path.
• Implementation notes: puzzles should be robust to latency and should have fallback solutions to prevent deadlocks. Use visual feedback and timers that reward exchange between roles.
• Balancing: keep puzzles brief (30–90 seconds) and design fail-states that still leave both teams engaged (e.g., partial progress unlocks smaller rewards).
• Telemetry: completion rates, average time-to-solve, and how puzzle success correlates with match outcomes.

7. Social / Influence (Diplomatic)

Multiplayer translation: control narratives through faction reputation, sway NPC factions, or complete objectives that alter in-match allegiances.

ARC Raiders example: "Broker an Alliance" — both teams can influence a neutral NPC faction by performing favors (defend caravans or free hostages). Faction alignment grants map-level buffs.

• Design pattern: introduces soft power objectives and long-term incentives across rounds or a session's meta-game.
• Implementation notes: ensure influence actions are visible and reversible; allow players to counter-influence to create tug-of-war dynamics.
• Balancing: cap influence gains per match to keep effects meaningful but bounded; design influence decay between matches to prevent runaway advantages.
• Telemetry: influence swings per match, correlation with match length, and player engagement with social objectives versus pure combat roles.

8. Build / Repair (Construction)

Multiplayer translation: erect or restore objectives — build barricades, repair terminals, or assemble devices under enemy pressure.

ARC Raiders example: "Bridge Restoration" — teams have to reconstruct a damaged bridge over several stages to open a new flank; attackers can snipe builders or set demolition traps.

• Design pattern: longer-term team projects that reward planning, resource allocation, and area control.
• Implementation notes: give builders unique utility gear and defendable build zones; ensure building actions are interruptible but have partial progress persistence to reward sustained effort.
• Balancing: use resource gating (repair kits, power nodes) and multiple concurrent build sites to prevent overinvestment in a single area.
• Telemetry: build completion rates, average resources spent, and impact on matchflow when a build completes or is destroyed.

9. Saga / Multi-stage Narrative

Multiplayer translation: chain objectives across a match or series of matches to create a short narrative arc with escalating stakes.

ARC Raiders example: a seasonal "Invasion Thread" where matches contribute to an evolving event: round one unlocks a map lockdown, round two spawns elite AI, round three offers a final, match-defining raid boss.

• Design pattern: stitches together single-objective patterns into a memorable arc that drives session-to-session retention.
• Implementation notes: make each stage win or lose meaningful for the next; use server-side state and clear UI progression bars so players feel their contributions matter.
• Balancing: provide catch-up mechanics and ensure stage fail-states still give players small wins to preserve engagement.
• Telemetry: stage completion rates, churn between stages, and engagement lift from multi-stage events.

Practical design patterns: mixes and variants for shooters

One of Cain’s key points is that variety, not sheer quantity, makes a game feel rich. Here are practical ways to combine the archetypes to create modular objectives that scale across map sizes (a nod to ARC Raiders’ 2026 roadmap for diverse map scales):

• Mini-objective clusters: scatter 2–3 short Fetch/Intel nodes that funnel players into a central Kill or Escort objective. Great for small maps and quick-session design.
• Asymmetric pipelines: give one team Build/Repair tasks while the other executes Eliminate/Intercept tasks — fosters role differentiation and emergent counter-play.
• Reactive puzzles: tie Puzzle objectives to immediate combat outcomes; if attackers fail, spawn a Retrieve objective for defenders, maintaining match momentum.
• Seasonal saga layers: use the Saga archetype to make weekly rotations: one week emphasizes Investigation nodes for map mastery; the next ramps up Escort events for coordinated play.

Engineering considerations and cost control

Tim Cain warned that "more of one thing means less of another" — the same is true for engineering budgets. Use these strategies to increase objective variety without exploding production costs:

• Parameterize objectives: build one Fetch system and make it configurable (spawn points, timers, carrier debuffs) so it can behave like many distinct objectives.
• AI event toolkit: create modular AI roles (boss, harasser, convoy) that can be slotted into different quest archetypes.
• Procedural placement: use simple procedural rules for node placement (cover density, sightlines, distance to spawn) so designers can create new objective maps quickly.
• Telemetry-driven iteration: instrument every objective with a small set of core metrics so designers can prune low-performing variants fast.

Player engagement and reward design in 2026

Varied objectives only pay off if players feel rewarded for their play style. In 2026, players expect both immediate feedback and long-term progression:

• Short-term: instant XP and micro-rewards for objective-specific actions (carrier assists, successful puzzles solved). These keep players satisfied match-to-match.
• Medium-term: role-specific progression (engineer ranks, scout talents) to reward mastery of non-lethal objectives like Puzzle and Investigate.
• Long-term: Saga-linked cosmetics and faction reputation that carry across seasons — make Influence and Social objectives tie into these meta systems.

Anti-abuse & accessibility guardrails

Objectives that invite new behaviors also invite creative abuse. Plan for these from day one:

• Implement soft fail-safes for hostage/escort griefing (auto-rescue timers, anti-stall events).
• Use role rotation incentives so single players don’t monopolize high-value objectives.
• Design UI clarity — mark objective carriers, show countdowns, and provide accessible controls for puzzle sequences (alternatives for players with motor or visual impairments).
• Keep matches short and offer quick-swap re-queue for players frustrated by a bad objective roll.

Telemetry checklist — what to measure

Instrument objectives with consistent metrics so you can iterate quickly:

• Objective engagement rate (percent of players who interact with the objective).
• Time-to-completion and percent of matches completing objective.
• Role participation (which classes/roles engage the most).
• Post-objective win probability to measure whether an objective is game-deciding.
• Player retention lift per objective type (do puzzle players stay longer than escort players?).

Quick design recipes you can implement this week

1. Small map 10–12 min match: one Fetch node + one Kill miniboss that spawns after the fetch. Reward: minor XP + team buff. Why it works: quick loop with a climax.
2. Mid map 15–20 min match: Escort + Puzzle gates. The escort must pass through two locked doors that require short puzzles each. Reward: temporary flanking route unlocked. Why it works: teams shift roles and communicate.
3. Large map 20+ min match: Saga mini-stage: Stage 1 (Investigate nodes) feeds into Stage 2 (Build/Repair a forward base) and Stage 3 (Eliminate a raid boss). Reward: seasonal currency + exclusive cosmetic. Why it works: creates memorable narrative progression and rewards long sessions.

ARC Raiders-specific recommendations (2026 roadmap aligned)

Embark Studios is shipping multiple maps in 2026 across different sizes; use these objective patterns to keep old maps feeling new and to maximize the value of each new arena:

• For smaller maps: favor Fetch, Kill, and short Puzzle objectives. These fit shorter session goals and the tighter sightlines Embark hinted at.
• For larger maps: deploy Saga and Escort arcs that make use of traversal tools and map mastery. Add Investigation nodes that reward players who learn the map rotations.
• Rotate objective suites on existing maps to refresh meta-play: a Blue Gate match focused on Deliver/Puzzle this week can become an Escort/Investigation map the next.
• Use map-level events (storms, AI reinforcements) to dynamically alter objective behavior mid-match — this increases replayability without needing new assets.

Final takeaways — how to ship objective variety with confidence

• Start with archetypes: use Cain’s nine quest types as templates — not rigid boxes — to mix and match objectives across maps.
• Parameterize and re-use systems: you don’t need nine separate systems; make flexible systems that cover many archetypes.
• Instrument aggressively: build feedback loops so telemetry tells you what to prune or amplify.
• Prioritize player clarity: varied objectives only succeed if their goals and rewards are transparent in-match.
• Leverage 2026 tech: AI-driven events, procedural placement, and cross-session saga states let you deliver variety with lower content overhead.

Action checklist — launch-ready objective blueprint

1. Pick 3 archetypes for a map: one short (Fetch), one medium (Escort), one climactic (Kill or Saga).
2. Parameterize spawn points, health/difficulty, and reward tiers for each archetype.
3. Implement visual/audio telegraphs and carrier debuffs for all mobile objectives.
4. Hook objectives into progression (cosmetics, faction rep) so players care beyond a single match.
5. Ship a 2-week A/B test and monitor the telemetry checklist above.

Closing — build objectives players remember, not just repeat

Tim Cain’s taxonomy is a design swiss army knife: it gives you nine distinct lenses to think about the player's motivation. In 2026, with live services, AI-driven events, and new map sizes coming to games like ARC Raiders, translating those archetypes into modular multiplayer objectives is the fastest way to increase meaningful variety. Start small — parameterize, instrument, and iterate — and you'll get more memorable matches without exploding the engineering budget.

Try this now: pick one existing map and swap a neutral control point for a short Fetch + Kill combo. Monitor the teleport graphs and player role participation for one week. You'll see engagement shift within days.

Want more blueprint packs and telemetry dashboards tuned for shooter objectives? Sign up for our design kit and get a free objective param-set tailored for ARC Raiders-style maps, plus a checklist you can drop into your live build pipeline.

Ready to diversify your matches? Implement one Cain-inspired objective this week and watch how simple variety improves player retention and creates stories players actually talk about.

Related Reading

• Plan a Parent Education Night on Medications and Safety: How to Host Experts and Protect Privacy
• Packing for a Multi-Destination 2026 Trip: Phone Plans, Passes and Bus Options
• Winter Commuter Essentials: Extra-Fleecy Covers, Wearables and Energy-Saving Tips
• Make Your Own Cocktail Syrups at Home: From Stove-Top Test Batch to Small-Batch Pantry Staples
• How small retailers (like Liberty) choosing new leadership can change premium pet ranges